Moderator: ZS Global Moderators
tookieblueeyes wrote:Crazy Wolf wrote:DaleGribble wrote:Noodling is actually illegal in most states IIRC
And foolish in all of them. What's worth more to your survival, a hand or a catfish?
Noodling may seem foolish but Native Americans have fished for catfish in this way long before white man ever set foot on American soil and they HAD to do it for SURVIVAL to FEED themselves AND their families. Besides... catfish in this country don't have teeth that can rip a whole hand off... their gums are lined with raspy pads that are suited for grabbing and holding onto their meals so your knuckles are gonna get scraped up like you rubbed them rough on a piece of sandpaper, but they aren't going to rip your hand off like a bull shark and 5 yards! They may take a finger, that is possible if you have a big enough one on hand, and if they are good fighters and stronger than you are and you aren't smart enough to know when the hell you should let go then they could drown you... yes... but that is where you have to remember to noodle responsibly and know when to hold um and know when to fold um like Kenny Rogers would say in the Gambler
http://crazyhorsesghost.hubpages.com/hub/Noodling_What_Is_It_And_Is_It_Legal
http://www.welcomefishermen.com/index.php/pages/noodlingcatfish.html


Crazy Wolf wrote:First off: catfish aren't the only things that like to live in hollows in the riverbanks, some of which *can* take your fingers off or envenomate you, resulting in you being both horribly injured and hungry, and secondly, just because the natives did it doesn't mean it's a wise decision (see: counting coup, although IIRC that's a more Plains thing). However, you did mention that it was a a "survival" method, which would allow for you to recognize that it has some utility while admitting that it isn't the best idea to do if you have other options (see: having a Bear Grylls martini).

Crazy Wolf wrote:First off: catfish aren't the only things that like to live in hollows in the riverbanks, some of which *can* take your fingers off or envenomate you, resulting in you being both horribly injured and hungry, and secondly, just because the natives did it doesn't mean it's a wise decision (see: counting coup, although IIRC that's a more Plains thing). However, you did mention that it was a a "survival" method, which would allow for you to recognize that it has some utility while admitting that it isn't the best idea to do if you have other options (see: having a Bear Grylls martini).
Blitzen2k5 wrote:Sorry Crazy Wolf but I have to disagree. Mainly because I think you just have the media's take on noodling and not the real story. I have extended family that are noodlers. Some 30 or so Oklahoma hillbillies that all noodle every chance they get. Yah they get hurt from time to time. Its usually just strains or sprains more then anything else. Every so often, once a year or so, you hear about one of them getting snake bit or turtle snapped. Yet they havent died and I have yet to see a single one of them missing a finger or hand. Decades and generations of noodlers and hardly any serious accidents, that is a pretty good track record. Better then some other food gathering methods in a survival situation.




Crazy Wolf wrote:After getting snakebit or turtle-snapped, do these relatives of yours go to a hospital, or does the problem resolve itself without the aid of medical professionals?

BattleVersion wrote:For my Family?...
Burn down the world, sure... But, I'm also willing to carry it on my shoulders.

Blitzen2k5 wrote:Crazy Wolf wrote:After getting snakebit or turtle-snapped, do these relatives of yours go to a hospital, or does the problem resolve itself without the aid of medical professionals?
Sometimes they did go to the doctor but a lot of times they use more "country" methods.
Crazy
You dont want to hunt or fish for survival either huh? Dont want to grow food either? Cause I hate to break this to you bro.... In nature anything can get you hurt or killed. I know of people got snake bit while tending a garden. One dude got mauled by a bear just checking his mail. A nice safe thing like that in nature and wow there are risks. Who knew?
Really if your scared of getting hurt in a survival situation I dont know what to tell you. Avoid nature. That is all I can say. Just in my state we got all sorts of ways to die or get seriously injured just a few feet from a camp site. Bears, boars, mountain lions, copperheads, rattlers, cottonmouths, coyotes, alligators, 5 different kinds of spiders, a couple of types of scorpions.... Heck we even got a few plants here that just brushing bare skin up against them can make you seriously ill.
So my advice, if a PAW happens just dont leave the city. Stay away from nature. Cause if you got a fear of getting hurt while noodling as a food gathering source.... Well you dont want to be out in the bush at all. Everything you do can risk serious injury. I grew up in the woods of Oklahoma. I know a lot of those places like the back of my hand (Oh when did that wart grow there?). And I am not 100% safe out there. You could know exactly what you doing. Been doing it all your life. Had more training then a PhD in doing it and your still risking getting hurt while doing it.
Think about this. Dont just dismiss it. If your scared of getting snake bit while noodling... Well fishing from a shore here can get you snake bit at about the same ratio. Hunting small or large game can get you attacked by all sorts of things with college degrees in people killing. Setting traps as well. Dude you can get all sorts of nasty injuries just gathering wood for your fire a few feet from your camp. Nature is not to be dismissed or trifled with. You gotta respect it. Watch where you walk. Dont set up camp near game trails. Stay alert. Listen to it. And above all else follow the rules. Even then there is risk.
DaleGribble wrote:You're missing the point. As one of the stars of one of my favorite survival shows, Cody Lundin of Dual Survival, says, "You don't go after something that can put a hurt on you." Now I do understand teh limitations of this statement, but the principle stands... Noodling isn't the best method as far as survival in a PAW, to catch a fish. Especially a fish that is notoriously easy to catch with the simplest of tackle.



Crazy Wolf wrote:Blitz, your tone seems rather condescending. You are advocating popping into an environment where you have vastly decreased visibility (a sense that's quite important for humans), vastly decreased mobility (a trait that's quite important for most mammals), and where you can't see what you're hunting or what's attacking you. You advocate this, because if you are successful in noodling, then you get a giant catfish, an animal which could most likely be retrieved with a fishing pole and line, from a position where you can see and move. To me, the risks of noodling far outweigh the reward of "don't have to carry around a fishing pole!".


BattleVersion wrote:For my Family?...
Burn down the world, sure... But, I'm also willing to carry it on my shoulders.

DaleGribble wrote:Friend of mine was out yesterday, caught another snakehead. Anyone familiar with these or caught them before?
DaleGribble wrote:From what I understand they really aren't doing that much damage to native species up hear in VA. I''m not too sure really, there are groups that go around electrofishing them out as well. No release policy and these things used to have a bounty on them. TOo many were being caught though.
Fun to catch and they taste good too!


Crazy Wolf wrote:DaleGribble wrote:From what I understand they really aren't doing that much damage to native species up hear in VA. I''m not too sure really, there are groups that go around electrofishing them out as well. No release policy and these things used to have a bounty on them. TOo many were being caught though.
Fun to catch and they taste good too!
They're a pretty bad invasive species. I'm not if they're legitimately delicious, or it's just ecologically-conscious gourmets who are insisting that they are as pretty much the only way to even *think* of curbing their numbers. But either way, catch them, kill them, eat what you want.
Visionz wrote:This is funny...
If I told you I was into extreme motocross, I doubt I would catch shit, and in fact I might be considered "cool".
If I tell you I noodle, I'm a dumb fucking hillbilly.
One does not feed you and statistically gives you a better chance of serious injury or dying.
The other puts food on the table and if done properly is relatively safe.


Busted Arse wrote:maddmatt wrote:Structure. Points, drop-offs, bush piles, river channels, rock piles, and grass beds, find structure and you will usually find the fish.
This! Best advice in this thread.

Return to Self-Sufficient Living
Users browsing this forum: LazyMonkey and 5 guests