DarkScythe wrote:Im sure everybody on here carries either a Surefire or Fenix brand of Led flashlight.
Nope, I love cool flashlights as much as the next guy, but I gravitate towards lights that meet my needs over just the "wow factor."
My every day carry light is a little Arc AA. It's just under 3" and runs on a single AA. I use it as my keyring so I *always* have it handy. It's just small enough to do that. It's bright enough to handle any "normal" lighting task and I use it all the time for chores ranging from looking for things in my car to finding my way around darkened theaters to running out to the backyard to check the pool motor without having to turn on the yard lights. It also gives a very nice run time with standard alkaline AA batts and even better with a Lithium AA, when I remember to buy one. Usually I just canabalize any convenient AA nearby when the battery goes dead. Ease of replacement batteries is one of the things I like about it. (The original price was $20, NIB, on a special sale. That version of ARC is now out of business though and the light is no longer available)
I also have a Surefire, an Executive E1E (I think?) but I gave up using that for an EDC. While it's noticeably brighter, the run time isn't long enough. I get tired of replacing the 123 batts on a regular basis. I'm not even sure where it is right now. I may mount it on my rifle or shotgun as a weapon light. That would get some use out of it and the low run time isn't as much of a problem there and the brightness is definately an advantage for that task.
I also have an ARC that uses 123's that I keep in my car. It's just over 3" and I used to use it as a key ring before I got the smaller ARC AA. It also has a larger diameter then the ARC AA so the overall size and bulkiness is greater. I like it, it's brighter then a Mag lite or the ARC AA, but has the same problem with runtime and batteries as the Surefire.
When I need a light to carry brighter then my ARC AA I once again turn to the standard MiniMag AA. Yeah, it's old tech, and there are better and brighter lights out there, but it's inexpensive, uses common batteries, is bright enough for what I need, and has a much better run time then any of the CR123 battery lights I use.
We just had to clean out my Grandfather's 100 year old farmhouse after he died. The power was out and most of the house was dark with the basement being absolutely black. The Minimag and a cheap 4 AA Wal Mart light where the two lights that worked the best. They had the longest run time and were bright enough for the job. The ARC 123 was brighter, which was nice, but went dead not too long into the first day. The little ARC AA was always in my pocket and I used it to find my way out of the basement when the ARC 123 went into "moon mode", which wasn't bright enough to navigate that minfield of debris.
So, what's out there that has a good run time, uses a single AA battery, is no longer then 3" and is brighter then my ARC AA? Anything? If there is, I may replace my ARC AA as I know the tech has improved since that light came out. So far though, it's worked best as my EDC.